Analysis
How to Find Rule XVI Violations in Minibus
A practical guide to identifying appropriations provisions that may run afoul of Rule XVI.
Why the Senate Needs Unanimous Consent to Advance Minibus
This piece explains why moving a minibus through the Senate often depends less on raw majority power than on unanimous consent.
Senate Republicans Could Enforce Earmark Ban If They Wanted To
Senate rules and party practices may give Republicans more leverage over earmarks than they are using.
Earmark Dispute Stalls Senate Minibus
How substantive disagreements can quickly become floor-management problems when senators don’t follow their own party rules.
Minibus Proponents Look to Circumvent the Senate Rules
When rules constrain action, lawmakers look for ways around them.
Schumer Sets Up Senate Minibus Debate
Senate leaders use procedure to shape floor outcomes before debate even begins.
The Senate Minibus, Unanimous Consent, and Rule XVI Points of Order
One point of order can derail an entire legislative strategy.
Senate Minibus Violates Rule XVI
Rule violations matter—even if they aren’t always enforced.
Evaluating the Minibus Amendment Process
McConnell Maintained Control With Blocker Amendment
How to Spot Policy Riders in Appropriations Bills
Identifying rule violations gives senators leverage and/or hooks for amendments.
Losing Isn’t Required To Play The Game
Senators don’t have to accept higher vote thresholds for their amendments.
